That’s fun to say. Try it! “Apple cookie epiphany.” Now say it five times fast. Seriously, try it!
I had these cookies once before. It was back when Nick and I first started dating, and it had never occurred to me that you could put fruit in a cookie. Cookies had chocolate, or they weren’t worth eating. (I was addicted to sugar back then. I sought help, but it didn’t take. Luckily, I discovered that fruit has sugar in it, too.)
Nick has been asking for these cookies ever since he moved out of his parents’ house (now you know how long we’ve been together), but I thought I had to get the recipe from his mom, and I have a terrible memory. So he’s suffered for years because it never occurred to me that I could make cookies and just put apple in them instead of chocolate chips! The next time you see my husband, tell him that you are sorry he’s had to live with such an unthoughtful wife for so many years. Give him a hug, and tell him that there’s hope for me yet.
When I had my apple cookie epiphany, I didn’t want to use my go-to amazing oatmeal cookie recipe. Why? Well, because it isn’t the most health-conscious recipe. At all, really. I mean, it has oatmeal, which is good. And eggs, which are good too, but it also has quite a bit of butter and flour. Both good in moderation, but these cookies had never heard the word. So, I decided to just “tweak” my recipe a bit.
After creaming the butter, applesauce and sugars, I added one whole egg, one egg white and some vanilla. And then comes my secret weapon:
I took whole oats, and then blended them to make oat flour
I added the oat flour, some regular flour, baking soda and baking powder to the butter mixture, and then just barely combined all the ingredients. You don’t want to over mix these cookies, or you’ll end up with a dense, sticky, delicious mess!
I then took two gorgeous honey crisp apples, diced them and added them to the dough. At this point, I had to switch to a wooden spoon to combine everything.
After that, I dropped the cookies onto my stoneware pan and baked them.
And then these emerged!
Perfectly soft, perfectly appley. I loved that the actual cookie wasn’t too sweet, because it really let the apples shine through. You could eat these with coffee, tea, for breakfast, for dessert… When I asked my poor deprived husband how they tasted, he replied with a quick “good,” but most of the cookies have disappeared since then, leaving me to believe that he likes them. My son, who did not inherit my sweet tooth, asked for a cookie for breakfast this morning, so you can believe me when I say that these cookies are delicious!
Have fun with this recipe, and let me know how they turn out!
Makes approximately 36 cookies, depending on how much dough you eat
3/4 cup butter (room temperature)
1/4 cup applesauce
3/4 cup sugar (this is the amount I used, not my future amount, if that makes sense?)
3/4 cup brown sugar (same as above?)
1 egg white
1 1/2 tsp vanilla
2 cups flour
2 1/2 cups oatmeal (this is the amount before blending)
1 tsp baking powder
1 tsp baking soda
1 1/2 to 2 large apples, chopped
Preheat oven to 375F. Cream butter, applesauce and both sugars. Add eggs and vanilla and mix. Add flour, oats, baking powder and baking soda and mix just to combine. (If you don’t get the last dusting of flour mixture to combine, it’s ok, because you’re still going to have to add the apples. The moisture from the apples will help grab the last bit of flour.) Add the apples and combine.
Drop onto a cookie sheet or stoneware pan, and bake until golden brown.
The baking time depends on the pans that you use. With my stoneware pans, it took anywhere from 15-20 minutes, but with a metal cookie sheet, the time is shorter–about 10-15 minutes.